I was a student at Colorado College, and suddenly my entire chin swelled up like a baseball. The CC campus clinic recommended Dr. Doolittle, and he performed a double root canal later that same day (a Sunday!). No nurses were available on such short notice, so one of the other dentists came in to assist. The two of them told me jokes while they were operating and made me feel very relaxed. The best part was that he knew I'd have trouble getting my painkiller prescription filled quickly on a Sunday, so he made sure to give me extra shots of Novacaine right before I left his office so I wouldn't be in pain while my prescription was filled. And then he personally called me the next day to ask me how I was doing. I later went back for a cracked tooth, and Dr. Doolittle repaired it with a gold crown that other dentists have complimented several times.
CC has a Division I hockey team, and this is where players go when they get hit in the mouth with sticks and pucks. They could go anywhere (especially since the CC is paying) but they go to Dr. Doolittle. I think that says a lot.
If I still lived in C Springs, I'd definitely use Dr. Doolittle. He's a expensive, but worth it.