Dr. Sclaroff is top notch, however his administrative staff is horrendous. If you don't expect any complication with insurance, I would highly recommend his abilities as a surgeon. However, if you are faced with a more challenging procedure and may need to obtain pre-approval from your healthcare provider; know that you are on your own.
If you need any additional information (copies of x-rays, procedure pictures, etc) his staff is painfully slow, and at times downright rude.
In retrospect, I would still select him for his skill; after all quality of his work is what matters. However, I would probably take pain killers before dealing with his staff. (For the record, I was extremely nice to the staff when making request; it just seems that they are not used to handling anything more than scheduling appointments - and they even messed that up once)